Nica's Market: East Rock's Beloved Italian Grocery and Deli

Every great neighborhood in New Haven Connecticut has an anchor shop, the place where you run in for a loaf of bread and run into three people you know. In East Rock, that place is Nica's Market at 603 Orange Street, a family-run Italian grocery and deli that has anchored the corridor since 2002. It is the kind of spot that makes living in New Haven feel like a small town with an excellent deli, and regulars would not trade it for anything.

A family market that has fed East Rock for more than two decades, one sandwich and one jar of imported olive oil at a time.

A Storefront With a Story

Nica's carries the story of New Haven's generations of Italian families. Founder Giuseppe "Nica" Sabino came to the city from Italy and worked at the old Cott soda bottling plant before retiring early, moving back to Italy, and opening his first grocery store there in 1989. In 2002 he returned to New Haven to open Nica's Market in a storefront on Orange Street that had housed the Prime Meat Market since the 1920s. Today his children Tony and Rosanna share ownership, and the shop still feels like the family kitchen, only bigger and with better pasta.

What You Are Here To Eat

The heart of the place is the deli. Handcrafted sandwiches and paninis, stuffed breads, pizza by the slice, homemade soups and salads, and prepared hot meals land on the counter all day, and the shelves around them hold imported olive oils, artisan pastas, family-made pasta sauces, cookies, Italian gelato, and Italian sodas. Shoppers describe the experience the same way again and again: like walking through the streets of an old European village. The small BYOB patio out back, with free WiFi and old Italian classics playing, gives you a reason to linger.

Why East Rock Swears By It

For locals, Nica's is a ritual. Weekday lunch means a sandwich from the case, weekend mornings mean fresh produce and artisan cheese for a slow meal at home, and warm evenings mean the patio. When I show clients homes in this part of the city, I always point them to shops like this one, because a neighborhood that supports a family market for decades is a neighborhood with roots. If you are exploring East Rock and thinking about moving to New Haven, stop in and see how a community actually lives, not how a brochure describes it.

Plan a visit any day of the week: Nica's Market is open Monday through Saturday from 7:00 AM to 7:00 PM and Sunday from 7:00 AM to 4:00 PM, at 603 Orange Street. Call (203) 787-5919 or check nicasmarket.com for the day's specials. Orange Street runs from East Rock down toward downtown New Haven and Yale University, so it is an easy bike ride or a short drive from most of the city, and a quick detour from the things to do list any local would give you.

One More Reason New Haven Feels Like Home

Shops like Nica's are a big part of why people fall in love with this city, and they matter when you choose a neighborhood as much as the house itself. If you are exploring living in New Haven, whether you are relocating from out of state or just ready for a new part of town, I would love to help you find a home near your new favorite deli. Call Robert Clarke at Coldwell Banker Realty, (203) 936-9004, email rob@robandvicCT.com, or visit robandvicct.com to schedule a conversation about New Haven real estate.

About the Author

Robert Clarke is a licensed Connecticut real estate agent with 30 years of experience helping families buy and sell homes across New Haven and all of Connecticut. With a Master's degree from George Washington University and a background in systems engineering, Robert brings a thoughtful, analytical approach to New Haven real estate, and a genuine love for the neighborhood institutions that make this city special.

Contact Robert at (203) 936-9004 or rob@robandvicCT.com.

Learn more about Robert → · Get in touch →